Preparing for Medicare AEP: Avoid These Common Mistakes
September 17, 2025

Every year, from October 15 to December 7, Medicare beneficiaries have the opportunity to review and make changes to their Medicare coverage during the Annual Enrollment Period (AEP). This is the time to compare plans, switch Medicare Advantage or Part D plans, or go back to Original Medicare if your needs have changed.


Unfortunately, many people rush through this process—or skip it entirely—and end up with coverage that doesn’t match their needs. Here are some common mistakes to avoid in 2025 so you can make the most of AEP and avoid unnecessary expenses or disruptions in care.


Mistake #1: Ignoring Your Annual Notice of Change (ANOC)



Your plan may look the same—but that doesn’t mean it is. Each September, your current plan will mail you an Annual Notice of Change that outlines any changes to premiums, drug formularies, provider networks, and copayments.


Why it matters: Even a small change in your prescription coverage or provider network can lead to unexpected costs or loss of access to your doctor.


Tip: Review your ANOC carefully, especially if you have regular prescriptions or see specialists.


Mistake #2: Assuming You Can ‘Set It and Forget It’



Medicare is not one-size-fits-all. Your health needs, finances, and provider preferences can shift from year to year.


Why it matters: A plan that worked for you last year might not be the best choice this year. Formularies change, premiums go up, and networks shift.


Tip: Use Medicare’s official Plan Finder at Medicare.gov/plan-compare to compare plans based on your ZIP code, medications, and preferred providers.


Mistake #3: Missing the Enrollment Window


AEP runs from October 15 through December 7. Changes you make during this period take effect January 1, 2026.


Why it matters: If you miss this window, your options may be limited. Unless you qualify for a Special Enrollment Period, you may have to wait until the next AEP to make changes.


Tip: Mark your calendar now and schedule time to review your options—ideally in early October to avoid last-minute stress.


Mistake #4: Not Reviewing Drug Coverage


Even if your medications haven’t changed, your Part D drug plan might have. Drug tiers, prior authorizations, and formularies are updated every year.


Why it matters: A medication you’ve taken for years could suddenly cost more—or be dropped entirely from your plan.


Tip: Make a list of your medications and dosage, then verify coverage under your current or new plan.


Mistake #5: Relying on Outdated Advice


Medicare is constantly evolving. What was true last year may no longer apply in 2025. While friends and family mean well, their advice may not reflect your personal circumstances or current Medicare rules.


Tip: Work with a licensed agent who specializes in Medicare and stays current on policy changes. Be sure they represent multiple carriers so you get objective comparisons.


Mistake #6: Forgetting to Check Your Providers


Provider networks in Medicare Advantage Plans can change annually. Just because your doctor is in-network now doesn’t guarantee they will be next year.


Tip: Confirm your preferred doctors, specialists, and hospitals are still in-network for the upcoming year before you re-enroll.


Bottom Line


The Medicare Annual Enrollment Period is your chance to fine-tune your health coverage and avoid unpleasant surprises in the year ahead. But skipping the review—or assuming nothing has changed—can cost you.


If you need help comparing plans or understanding what’s changed for 2025, we’re here to help. Reach out for a no-obligation review and get confident about your Medicare choices.

A person exercises on a leg press machine at a gym, with their feet pushing against the elevated weight plate.
By Kevan Brooks April 8, 2026
Many Medicare Advantage supplemental benefits go unused. Learn what’s included—like dental, vision, OTC allowances, and more—and how to maximize your plan’s value.
Hands with red-painted nails hold a small cluster of round, white scored tablets over black pants.
By Kevan Brooks April 1, 2026
A Useful Way to Manage High Drug Costs Prescription medications can be one of the most expensive parts of healthcare for people on Medicare. For many beneficiaries, especially those taking specialty medications, the cost of prescriptions can quickly add up. In some cases, a single medication may cost hundreds or even thousands of dollars at the pharmacy. To help address this issue, Medicare introduced the Medicare Prescription Payment Plan , a program designed to make prescription drug costs more manageable by allowing beneficiaries to spread their out-of-pocket costs over time rather than paying them all at once. Unfortunately, many Medicare beneficiaries are not aware that this option exists. While this program is especially helpful for people who face high costs at the beginning of the year, it can also provide meaningful financial relief for those who are newly diagnosed with a serious condition and suddenly need expensive medications. You can learn more about the program directly from Medicare here: https://www.medicare.gov/prescription-payment-plan Why High Drug Costs Can Be Challenging Medicare Part D prescription drug plans often involve deductibles and cost-sharing that can create large upfront costs for medications. At the beginning of the year , these costs can feel especially burdensome because plan deductibles reset in January. Someone who fills a high-cost prescription early in the year may need to pay a large portion of the cost before their insurance begins covering more of the expense. But high costs don’t only occur in January. Many people experience significant prescription expenses when they receive a new diagnosis and start treatment for a condition such as cancer, autoimmune diseases, or other chronic illnesses. Specialty medications used to treat these conditions can be expensive, and the first prescription can create a financial shock for patients who were not expecting it. The Medicare Prescription Payment Plan helps by changing how those costs are paid , turning large one-time pharmacy bills into manageable monthly payments. How the Medicare Prescription Payment Plan Works The Medicare Prescription Payment Plan is available to anyone enrolled in a Medicare Part D prescription drug plan or a Medicare Advantage plan that includes drug coverage . Instead of paying your full out-of-pocket cost when you pick up a prescription at the pharmacy, the payment plan allows you to spread those costs out across monthly payments. Here’s how it works: Your Medicare drug plan pays the pharmacy for your prescription. Instead of paying the pharmacy directly, you receive a monthly bill from your drug plan . Your out-of-pocket prescription costs are divided into interest-free monthly payments over the remaining months of the calendar year. For example, if you fill an expensive prescription in February and enroll in the payment plan, your costs can be spread across the remaining months of the year instead of being paid all at once. It’s important to understand that this program does not reduce the total cost of your medications . Instead, it changes the timing of your payments so the cost is easier to manage. More details about how the program works are available here: https://www.medicare.gov/prescription-payment-plan Why This Program Helps at the Beginning of the Year Many people notice the biggest benefit of the program in January or February because that is when Medicare drug plan deductibles reset. Someone who takes a specialty medication may suddenly face a large pharmacy bill early in the year, before their plan begins covering more of the cost. By enrolling in the Medicare Prescription Payment Plan, that large upfront cost can be spread out across monthly payments, which can make a big difference for people living on fixed incomes. Why It Also Helps After a New Diagnosis The program can also be extremely helpful for people who are newly diagnosed with a serious illness . A new diagnosis often means starting treatment quickly, and the medications prescribed for conditions such as cancer, multiple sclerosis, rheumatoid arthritis, or other chronic diseases can be very expensive. Instead of paying a large pharmacy bill immediately after beginning treatment, the Medicare Prescription Payment Plan allows patients to break those costs into smaller monthly payments. This can help reduce financial stress during an already difficult time and may make it easier for patients to start treatment without delay. Who Is a Good Candidate for the Program? The Medicare Prescription Payment Plan may be particularly helpful for people who: Take high-cost specialty medications Expect to reach Medicare’s prescription drug spending limit during the year Prefer predictable monthly healthcare costs Have difficulty paying large pharmacy bills all at once Have been newly diagnosed with a condition requiring expensive medications On the other hand, people with relatively low prescription costs each month may not see much benefit from enrolling in the program. How to Enroll Enrollment in the Medicare Prescription Payment Plan is voluntary. If you have Medicare Part D coverage, you can contact your drug plan directly to ask about enrolling. The earlier you enroll in the year, the more months your payments can be spread across. However, you can typically enroll at any time during the year if you begin facing high prescription costs. Conclusion High prescription drug costs can create financial stress for many Medicare beneficiaries, particularly when expensive medications are needed unexpectedly. The Medicare Prescription Payment Plan offers a simple solution by allowing people to spread their prescription drug costs into interest-free monthly payments instead of paying the full amount at the pharmacy. Whether those costs appear at the beginning of the year or after a new diagnosis, this program can help make medications more financially manageable and provide greater predictability in healthcare expenses.
Two medical professionals reviewing a chart with a patient in a hospital bed.
By Kevan Brooks February 23, 2026
Medicare hospital coverage has limits. Learn how Medigap plans help cover extended hospital stays and reduce out-of-pocket costs.
Group of six people smiling, sitting on mats outdoors, enjoying the sun.
By Kevan Brooks February 16, 2026
Learn seven research-backed lifestyle changes that can help reduce your risk of dementia and Alzheimer’s and support long-term brain health.
Woman holds laughing child indoors, both smiling.
By Kevan Brooks February 9, 2026
Discover how single parents can protect their children with the right life insurance plan. Learn about coverage amounts, policy types, guardianship, and beneficiary planning.
Doctor holding a red heart, smiling. Stethoscope around her neck.
By Kevan Brooks February 2, 2026
February is American Heart Month. Learn simple, preventive steps to support heart health and understand how insurance benefits can help.
Person running on a paved path, wearing white running shoes and black shorts.
By Kevan Brooks January 30, 2026
Discover how consistent daily routines improve sleep, mood, energy, and overall well-being—and how small habits can help your body thrive.
Brown envelope with
By Kevan Brooks January 28, 2026
What To Do If You Are Denied
Elderly person fallen on a rug, holding knee, cane and glasses nearby, with a tipped-over chair in the background.
By Kevan Brooks January 23, 2026
Fall monitors help seniors stay safe and independent. Learn how fall detection devices work, why they matter, and how Medicare Advantage plans may help cover the cost.
Woman holding a Medicare health insurance card, smiling. Card shows name, and Part A/B dates of 01-01-2024.
By Kevan Brooks January 16, 2026
Enrolled in a new Medicare plan? Read practical tips to help you transition smoothly, from reviewing plan materials and sharing your new ID card to confirming coverage and prescriptions.
Show More